Supreme Court judge condemns keeping man in jail for life over theft

"This man’s life sentence for a failed attempt to steal a set of 3 hedge clippers is grossly out of proportion to the crime and serves no legitimate penal purpose."


Bernette Johnson, chief justice for the Louisiana Supreme Court, wrote a fiery dissent last week to the court's decision to turn away a review request of a man who is serving a life sentence for attempted theft.

Fair Wayne Bryant was arrested in 1997, accused of entering a carport in Shreveport, La., and stealing a pair of hedge clippers. Bryant admitted that he went into carport, but said that he was looking for spare gas because his car had broken down. The clippers that police found in his car, Bryant claimed, belonged to his wife.

Bryant was charged with attempted simple burglary of an inhabited dwelling and convicted of the crime later in 1997. Because it was Bryant's fifth felony conviction, prosecutors invoked harsh habitual offender laws that resulted in a life sentence in prison without parole.

Of his previous four felonies, three of them were nonviolent.

In 2000, Louisiana’s 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals said that Bryant's sentence was appropriate since he had spent so much time in prison already as an adult.

"This litany of convictions and the brevity of the periods during which defendant was not in custody for a new offense is ample support for the sentence imposed in this case," the appeals court ruled at the time.

In 2001, the Louisiana Supreme Court declined to hear Bryant's direct appeal; Johnson dissented in that case too.

Nearly 20 years later, Bryant's case made its way back to Louisiana's highest court, this time stemming from a 2018 appeal that argued that Bryant was illegally sentenced and should have been appointed legal counsel during a resentencing hearing.

The latest appeal, however, was rejected by a higher court and last Friday and the state Supreme Court followed suit, according to The Lens NOLA — a nonprofit news site based in New Orleans that first reported the story.

In her dissent, Johnson — the court's only Black justice — said that the state's habitual offender laws are a “modern manifestation” of the “Pig Laws," that are unjust and were widely used during Reconstruction to continue the oppression of Black people in the American South.

"Since his conviction in 1997, Mr. Bryant’s incarceration has cost Louisiana taxpayers approximately $518,667.

Arrested at 38, Mr. Bryant has already spent nearly 23 years in prison and is now over 60 years old," Johnson wrote. "If he lives another 20 years, Louisiana taxpayers will have paid almost one million dollars to punish Mr. Bryant for his failed effort to steal a set of hedge clippers."

She added: "This man’s life sentence for a failed attempt to steal a set of 3 hedge clippers is grossly out of proportion to the crime and serves no legitimate penal purpose."

Read more

Joe Biden establishes commission to study expanding Supreme Court

President Biden signed an executive order Friday establishing a commission to study whether to add seats to the Supreme Court and other reform proposals, the White House announced, fulfilling a promise he made on the campaign trail. The commission will be chaired by former White House counsel Bob Bauer and Cristina Rodriguez, a Yale law school professor and former deputy assistant attorney general, and largely consists of academics and former officials from across the political spectrum.

Supreme Court refuses quick action on last-ditch Trump election lawsuits

The Supreme Court on Monday rejected efforts by President Donald Trump and his allies to get the court to quickly consider challenges to President-elect Joe Biden’s victory in the November election, effectively shutting the door on the president’s last-ditch legal strategy to overturn his defeat.

Joe Biden plans special commission to suggest reforms

Joe Biden has confirmed he would appoint a special commission to study the US court system over 180 days, if he is elected next month, to provide reform recommendations relating to the supreme court and beyond.

Senate to vote Monday to confirm Amy Coney Barrett

The Senate will vote Monday on confirming President Trump's nominee, Judge Amy Coney Barrett, to the Supreme Court. "With regard to the Supreme Court justice ... we'll be voting to confirm justice-to-be Barrett next Monday," Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said during a weekly press conference, confirming the timing of a final vote on her nomination.